
| Year 2002 No. 122, June 28, 2002 | ARCHIVE | HOME | SEARCH | SUBSCRIBE |
|---|
Workers' Daily Internet Edition : Article Index :
An Agenda of Refusing to Accept Responsibility for Racism and Racial Discrimination
Daily On Line Newspaper of the
Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist)
170, Wandsworth Road, London, SW8 2LA. Phone 020 7627 0599
Web Site:
http://www.rcpbml.org.uk
e-mail:
office@rcpbml.org.uk
Subscription Rates (Cheques made payable to Workers' Publication
Centre):
Workers' Weekly Printed Edition:
70p per issue, £2.70 for 4 issues, £17 for 26 issues, £32
for 52 issues (including postage)
Workers' Daily Internet Edition sent by e-mail daily (Text
e-mail):
1 issue free, 6 months £5, Yearly £10
Home Secretary David Blunkett spoke to the Social Market Foundation on Wednesday, June 26, setting out what the Home Office called "a new agenda for tackling race inequality and discrimination, and promoting social cohesion in modern Britain". He also gave an interview with the BBC Asian network on the same day, elaborating on the speech he was to give.
According to the Home Secretary, everyone in Britain must tackle racism together, not because everyone is individually racist, but because "we" share the responsibility for dealing with the racism that exists in our society. WDIE refutes this conception of the problem of racism and racial discrimination, and affirms that the responsibility it takes up is to point the finger of blame at the state, to expose the agenda of the government to shrug off the burden of responsibility for racism, and to call on the working class and people to take up the struggle for the defence of the rights of all.
Individual prejudice is not the issue, whether it is considered that, as is sometimes said, "there is a bit of racism in each of us", or it is alleged that racist prejudice is a quality of the "extreme right". In a society where the very citizenship laws of the state are framed according to racist notions, where citizenship is equated with a "sense of belonging" and "Britishness", where immigration is decided according to racist criteria, where people seeking asylum are treated as criminals unless proved otherwise, there is no need to look anywhere but at the state for the source of racial discrimination and racist attacks. If racist thugs are allowed to act with impunity, then it cannot be otherwise than that they have the sanction of the state, where racist attacks are not directly organised or carried out by the state and its agents.
In his speech, David Blunkett elaborated on the liberal conception that "class inequality" is a key factor underpinning "race inequality" and explaining the "disadvantage experienced by ethnic minorities". According to this argument given by the Home Secretary, the more disadvantaged people are, the more they are likely to be frightened by an "influx" of "different cultures", and such communities provide a "breeding ground" for those that wish to "stir up racism". One might be thankful to the Home Secretary for stating this backward argument so clearly, with its conclusion that therefore that we have to "face the fact" that it is the breeding ground, and perhaps do something about the underlying disadvantage. The issue is that the "race inequality" is being used to divert on the one hand from developing the unity of all sections against the anti-social offensive, and on the other from providing the conditions for different cultures to flourish. The Home Secretary has been the very person notable for promoting the conception of the "influx of different cultures" as a problem. He therefore presents it as a problem stemming from the people who are prey to those that wish to "stir up racism", as though he were blameless in this respect. In addition he takes it as an axiom that you have "affluence in one part of the country and depravation in another", and furthermore that this is synonymous with "class inequality", as though if one were to magically iron out the affluence and depravation of different regions one would then end up with "class equality".
The Home Secretary goes on to stress that (in his view) racism is an individual and not an "institutional" phenomenon. He draws the conclusion that "prejudice and racism in its different forms must be faced down and tackled head on, even though the vast majority of people in this country are not racists". In this, he is taking issue with no less a person than the Director of Public Prosecutions, Sir David Calvert-Smith, who drew attention to "institutional racism", and, of course, with the Macpherson Report on the murder of Stephen Lawrence, which also indicted the problem of "institutional racism" in the police and others. David Blunkett's logic, therefore, is that people have to say, "look, we will do our bit". Leaving aside Blunkett's unspoken assumption that he does not have to do his "bit" questionable, one might say, given his utterances and actions as Home Secretary as regards to his prejudices against asylum seekers this also boils down to the assertion that the problem is endemic in certain individuals, who are to be regarded as divorced from the prevailing ideas and institutions in society. Once again, David Blunkett's treatment is designed to get society and in particular the government off the hook.
David Blunkett went on to address the important issue of social cohesion. It is a fact of life that social cohesion is under attack, and people led to feel their problems are peculiar to them as individuals. But the Home Secretary does not draw attention to the fact that the whole ethos promoted by the government as it steps up the anti-social offensive is that people must fend for themselves, that society should not be responsible for the wellbeing and care of its members. The orientation elaborated by Tony Blair's government is that its responsibility stops at providing the opportunities which individuals must grasp, and who are to be blamed if they do not grasp them. The "social mobility" promoted by Tony Blair which he alleges is the "motor of the market economy" runs directly counter to the need to safeguard the social fabric. However, in David Blunkett's interpretation, "social cohesion" is the equivalent of integration and assimilation, so that all share the same "sense of identity", of "belonging". According to this logic, racial prejudice runs counter to social cohesion, but the Home Secretary fails to identify the racism inherent in lumping everyone's "sense of identity" together, which is causing so much devastation among particularly young people of national minority communities. Blunkett's answer is a form of communitarianism, so that while he pays lip service to communities retaining their cultures and diversity, he opposes so-called "segregation". His answer is for people to "work together", to "tackle common problems" with the "resources" and "opportunities" that the government so thoughtfully provides. So he is led from talking about "social cohesion", which pertains to society as a whole, to instead talking about "community cohesion", which pertains to "civil society", and "adds a crucial dimension to the policy agenda". Thus, by sleight of hand, the government is again let off the hook (as opposed to "civil society"), so that "clearly" social cohesion becomes not "a matter for government alone".
This logic leads David Blunkett to assert that what is needed is a "new modern approach, one that recognises covert racism and glass ceilings", which "must include contributions from individuals and the wider community, and not simply government action". This approach is not new and modern, but one which is essentially a 19th century liberal one, based on the definition of a "civil society" of bourgeois right and representative democracy, in which the masses of the people do not have rights as human beings, and in which races from the colonies were considered as inferior and uncivilised, and the superior colonisers preached "toleration". Put another way, David Blunkett's call is for individuals of colour to be accommodated within a society which recognises only a hierarchy of rights, in which the electorate is excluded from political decision-making rather than all participating in the polity, of whatever nationality, on an equal basis. His call does not even extend to the 19th century liberal projects of great social programmes and reform, but recognises only the "positive contribution that migrants make to our economic and cultural life" and asks of them in turn for "the engagement with civic and community life which fosters understanding and a sense of identity and shared goals".
It is worth noting that the British government has also been at pains to absolve itself of any responsibility to right the wrongs of colonialism and slavery in which the historical roots of racism are to be found. This fact alone is sufficient to blow apart David Blunkett's pathetic pleadings that the answer to racism is that we should all do our bit. So far from "facing that down in its most stark form" (as Blunkett says apropos of depravation being a breeding ground for racism) and offering reparations for this monstrous crime against humanity, so far from recognising Britain's contemporary responsibility in Kosova, Afghanistan and elsewhere for the creation of "economic migrants" and people seeking asylum is the government's thinking that the Home Secretary coldly calculates a "net gain of £2½ billion" as the Treasury estimate of the "benefit of economic migration". "And if we can get that," David Blunkett says in his interview, "rather than unplanned and ad hoc asylum, where 90% of those who go through the appeals process actually do not get asylum status, but would if they came as economic migrants, [it would] be very welcome."
This underlines David Blunkett's fundamentally inhumane and racist approach to racism and racial discrimination. Immigration is looked at from the point of view of benefit to the state treasury, and poor and unskilled people who are seeking asylum or a new life in this country will only contribute to destroying "social cohesion" in the Home Secretary's definition, and fuelling racism.
As the state increases its oppression of the vulnerable and the government steps up its anti-social offensive, racism and racial discrimination are being promoted in the name of humanity, social cohesion and a modern agenda. They are being utilised in opposition to people moving forward in defence of the rights of all, and uniting in opposition to the anti-social offensive, as the crisis deepens. The government cannot be allowed to absolve itself of the responsibility for this racism and racial discrimination. On the contrary, the working class and people must resolutely refuse to be diverted from the course of defending the rights of all, and of bringing about a new society in which these rights are given a guarantee, the rights of all members of society as human beings are recognised, and the cultures and languages of all nationalities within Britain are provided with the conditions to flourish.