WDIE Masthead

Year 2002 No. 134, July 16, 2002 ARCHIVE HOME SEARCH SUBSCRIBE

Comprehensive Spending Review:

"Investment with Reform" Conditional on "Reform"

Workers' Daily Internet Edition : Article Index :

"Investment with Reform" Conditional on "Reform"

What the Opposition Parties Said

TUC Reaction to the CSR

For Your Reference:
The Chancellor's Spending Plans

Daily On Line Newspaper of the
Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist)

170, Wandsworth Road, London, SW8 2LA. Phone 020 7627 0599
Web Site: http://www.rcpbml.org.uk
e-mail: office@rcpbml.org.uk
Subscription Rates (Cheques made payable to Workers' Publication Centre):
Workers' Weekly Printed Edition:
70p per issue, £2.70 for 4 issues, £17 for 26 issues, £32 for 52 issues (including postage)

Workers' Daily Internet Edition sent by e-mail daily (Text e-mail):
1 issue free, 6 months £5, Yearly £10


Comprehensive Spending Review:

"Investment with Reform" Conditional on "Reform"

When Gordon Brown unveiled his plans for public sector spending on Monday, he emphasised that the settlements for Departments were conditional on tough new commitments to further reform across the public sector. Under this government, there were "no blank cheques".

Thus the details of the Comprehensive Spending Review reveal that the Chancellor is not investing in social programmes unconditionally to provide funding to meet the needs of all. Far from that being the case, his commitment to "reform" is the condition for providing "investment with reform". In other words, the government is committed to further reordering society so that it is geared to the needs of the financially oligarchy. This is so not only in the sense that funding in public services is geared to delivering them as sources of risk-free payments for the rich. It is also so in that the "standards" the government is demanding ensure that the arrangements – economic, political and social – of the society serve this same elite.

Thus the total of £61 billion in extra spending given to schools, hospitals, transport, law and order, and agriculture over the next three years has the aim of further reshaping society to accommodate all sections of the people within a society in all-round crisis. In such a reordered society, workers and working people as a whole must fit in with the imperatives of globalisation, or face the consequences.

In this respect, it is not coincidental that the Chancellor announced the biggest increase in spending on the British armed forces – £3.5 billion – for 20 years. According to Gordon Brown, this is necessary in order to rise to new challenges in a changed global environment. The Chancellor specified these international challenges as including the "essential duty of fighting terrorism". He related this to the "challenges here at home as global economic competition brings vastly increased opportunities but also increased insecurities". Thus the domestic and international challenges are tied together by the government’s role – "expanding educational, employment and economic opportunity and by encouraging stronger communities – to enable and empower people to make globalisation work for their families and their future".

Furthermore, since the events of September 11, Britain’s "international engagement" – the Chancellor said – has "assumed a new importance". In this context, he announced that the Foreign Secretary’s budget would rise from £1.3 billion this year to £1.5 billion by 2005-06.

When the Chancellor speaks of enabling and empowering people, he means not enabling them to have control of their lives and not empowering them as the decision-makers in society. One way of putting this would be to say that the Chancellor is proposing fascism in the name of democracy. How are the government’s reforms supposed to make globalisation work for people’s families and safeguard their future? He is taking progressive demands and turning them into rhetoric whose content is reactionary. The reality of the contemporary world is that neo-liberal globalisation is causing havoc, devastation and increasing global poverty and enslavement. Even as the Chancellor was speaking, the stock markets were plummeting. The attack on working people’s pensions is but one example of the effect of this collapse already. The government sees its role merely as "expanding … opportunity", while the "stronger communities" are supposed to take responsibility in a society in which individuals are being forced to fend for themselves. In this context, the Chancellor promoted further his conception of volunteerism. Calling for people to get the "chance to serve", Gordon Brown pledged £125 million for public service work

In terms of education, Gordon Brown said "resources and reform" had to go hand in hand. Extra cash is delivered to schools where "reform delivers real improvements". In this scenario, it is a condition for more resources that "failing institutions will be dealt with early and decisively". By what criteria? This is a prescription that schools must adopt the values decreed by the state. Society itself is not seen as being the cause of the problems in schools. The society must be in the government’s image, the logic goes, and the educational institutions must adapt. This education also is made to turn out pupils who will fit into a society in which the success of business in a globalised economy is paramount, and not how the future generation can question and change their conditions and take responsibility for safeguarding the future of society.

In what was seen as a blueprint for a third Labour term in office, Gordon Brown said new money must be allied to a programme of public service reform. "In each area of service delivery – from housing to education, from policing to defence – we are tying the new resources to reform and results, developing a modern way for efficient public services." He said he would be "setting demanding national targets" which would be independently audited by a new monitoring system. New public service agreements will be developed, to ensure that departments deliver the improvements demanded of them.

It has been easy for commentators to draw the conclusion that the move effectively boosts the Treasury's power base throughout Whitehall as a whole and gives the Chancellor an even greater stranglehold on the public service reform programme. Thus the government is planning to tackle head-on the "wreckers", that is, the public service workers and all those who point out that state funds should not be channelled straight into the pockets of private capital.

Nor is this all. The Chancellor said productivity was key to delivering sustained prosperity. The point was being made by the government that it was important to invest in the means to improve productivity. It was being made clear that it was not simply a matter of pouring money in, but ensuring that any investment was accompanied by reform. In other words, the "reform" that the "investment with reform" is being made conditional upon is also to ensure that the exploitation of working people is stepped up. The "empowerment" and "enabling" is therefore for the workers to accept responsibility also to ensure that their enterprises become competitive. This is what is being seen in the Post Office and elsewhere.

This is the meaning of "at the heart of our spending decisions this year is a set of major economic reforms to expand our national wealth so that Britain can be more productive and prosperous and make the most of new opportunities in the global economy". And also, "Invention and innovation are the key to long term national competitiveness, so in partnership with the Wellcome Trust we will create and fund a new National Centre for Excellence in Science Teaching and, after rigorous selection of priorities within the industry budget away from the old loss-making subsidies of the past." The Chancellor went on to say, "To remove barriers to productivity growth in the north and in the south of our country, the Deputy Prime Minister will this week announce reforms to our planning system, including Business Planning Zones to speed up development and create jobs in high unemployment areas." Under the guise of regeneration, further handouts are going to go to the monopolies while the workers have to pay by stepped up exploitation.

David Blunkett’s Home Office secured an additional £2.7 billion a year by 2005/06 after what was reported to be an intense round of 11th hour lobbying, but this is going on furthering the repressive apparatus of the state, including its own reforms, of "policing, asylum and criminal justice".

The speech was billed as a watershed for the government where it finally found new money for deep-rooted problems. It was aimed at setting out "a centre-left budget" for the next three years. But, the "centre-left" programme of the Third Way – of combating under-investment with "investment with reform" – is the programme the financial elite deem necessary to ensure that their maximum capitalist profits are put in a paramount position in the era of neo-liberal globalisation. This is the significance of the Chancellor’s Comprehensive Spending Review.

Article Index



What the Opposition Parties Said

The Conservatives said that the Chancellor's commitment to "real reform" across public services was a hollow promise.

From the Tory frontbench, Michael Howard said that the government was taxing more and delivering less. "Is not the lesson of the last five years that real money without real reform will not work," he said. "Isn't it abundantly clear that the Chancellor and his colleagues simply do not know how to bring about real reform and improvements in public services?" he asked.

"After all, he even set in place a whole panoply of public service agreements and targets and monitoring arrangements, so that all the extra money would deliver improvements in services," Michael Howard said. "And what has happened? The government has failed to meet its own targets. Failed over health care. Failed over violent crime. Failed over truancy."

He accused the government of failing on crime, schools and hospitals. "The same old promises, the same old failure," concluded the shadow chancellor.

The Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman, Matthew Taylor, said the Chancellor had cut income tax and eroded the quality of public services during the first parliament. Whilst he welcomed the new cash, Matthew Taylor questioned the government's ability to let frontline public services determine how the money should be spent. "The question for the Chancellor now is spending it well," he said.

The SNP Westminster leader, Alex Salmond, accused Gordon Brown of having neglected public services. "Having under-invested in public services for five years – after two decades of Tory under-funding – New Labour have now been forced to accept that our health, education and transport services are crumbling, and need more resources," he said.

Elfyn Llwyd, Plaid Cymru parliamentary leader, added that Wales was being left behind as England received extra funds. "In England, education spending is up by six per cent and health by 7.5 per cent, but the overall increase in the budget for public services in Wales is 5.1 per cent," he said.

"I am disappointed that once again Wales will not be able to match the increased investment in education and health being seen in England due to having to raid their budgets to match fund European objective one projects, he said. "This is indefensible and I challenge even the most slavishly loyal Labour backbencher to explain why Wales has to be sold short in this way."

Article Index



TUC Reaction to the CSR

Commenting on the Comprehensive Spending Review, TUC General Secretary, John Monks, said:

"This is another bold but balanced statement from the Chancellor. It is based on a measured and cautious assessment of the economic prospects which make the spending plans more than affordable.

"We strongly welcome the commitment to a devolved regional industrial strategy and the significant increase in the budgets of the Regional Development Agencies. It is also excellent to see manufacturing benefiting from extra funding for science, innovation and technology transfer.

"The extra money for education will be widely welcomed, not least because it once again places opportunity and advancement at the centre of the Government’s vision of the future.

"It is particularly good to see a commitment to broadening access to higher education through the maintenance allowance for 16-18 year olds from poorer backgrounds.

"It is also welcome that the government has been able to increase foreign aid, making further progress towards the UN target of 0.7% of GDP.

"Funding will best be followed by reform if the Government works in partnership with public servants and their unions rather than overloading them with Whitehall initiatives or threatening people with contracting out."

Article Index



For Your Reference:

The Chancellor's Spending Plans

Details of the departmental spending plans as announced by Gordon Brown.

Overall spending

Departmental spending will rise from £240 billion this financial year to £263 billion, £280 billion, and then £301 billion in 2005/06.

Spending will rise by an average 5.25 per cent a year in real terms.

Debt has been reduced from 44 per cent of national income in 1997 to 30.4 per cent last year.

Education and Skills

Six per cent a year real terms rise in education spending over the coming years, with the budget rising from £45 billion currently to £57.8 billion by 2005/06.

Education spending will reach 5.6 per cent of GDP in 2005/06.

The typical primary school is to receive £50,000 next year, and each April to 2005/06.

The typical secondary school got £115,000 last April, rising to £165,000 next April and £180,000 the following April and in years to 2005/06.

Educational maintenance allowances to be available nation-wide from September 2004, with up to £1500 a year available to 16-19 year olds from lower income families.

Higher education fund to rise to £90 million a year by 2005/06.

Funding will be available for 300,000 apprenticeship and training places for young people in 2004.

JobCentre Plus scheme will be rolled out nation-wide by 2005/06.

A new integrated budget for children, including childcare and early years learning, with a value of £1.5 billion by 2005/06 is to be created.

By October 2004 there will be a nursery place for every three to four year old who needs one.

Health

Real terms growth of 7.3 per cent.

Home Office

Budget to rise from £10.7 billion to £13.5 billion, a rise of £2.9 billion a year by 2005/06.

Overall spending on the criminal justice system will increase by an annual average of five per cent above inflation.

Number of work permits available to be expanded to 175,000 to tackle skills shortages.

The Active Community Unit, supporting the voluntary sector, will get £188 million over three years.

Work and Pensions

Departmental spending will rise from £7 billion this year to £7.8 billion in 2005/06, real terms growth of 1.1 per cent.

Just 0.4 per cent will be spent this year on "the costs of unemployment".

JobCentre Plus to expand nation-wide.

Ministry of Defence

Defence spending is to rise from £29.3 billion this year to £32.8 billion by 2005/06.

"The largest sustained real terms growth in defence spending for 20 years."

Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

£2.5 billion current budget rising to £2.9 billion in 2005/06.

Full funding for the recommendations of the Curry report on the future of farming and to improve flood defences.

International Development

Budget rising from £3.3 billion last year to £4.5 billion by 2005/06.

As a percentage of GDP, aid will rise from 0.26 per cent in 1997 to 0.32 per cent today and to 0.4 per cent by 2005/06. The United Nations target is for 0.7 per cent of spending to go towards aid.

Culture, Media and Sport

Spending will be £257 million higher in 2005/06 than it will be in 2002/03, rising to £31.5 billion.

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (local government and the regions)

Departmental housing budget to rise from £6 billion currently to £7.6 billion in 2005/06.

Departmental local government budget to rise from £37.6 billion currently to £45.89 billion in 2005/06.

Housing investment needs "a step change", with more homes for key workers. John Prescott is to detail the plans for reform on Thursday.

By 2005/06 £5.9 billion will be spent on housing (up from £4.8 billion this year), a 105 per cent real terms increase in housing budget since 1997.

Budget for the neighbourhood renewal fund rising from £400 million in 2003/04 to £525 million by 2005/06.

Local councils will have a real terms annual funding increase of 4.2 per cent.

Scotland

By 2005/06, the Scottish budget will be £4.1 billion more than at present.

Funds available to the Scottish executive and the Scotland Office will rise from £18.2 billion this year to £22.3 billion in 2005/06.

Wales Office

By 2005/06, the budget will be £2.3 billion more than at present.

Funds available to the Welsh assembly and the Wales Office will rise from £9.4 billion this year to £11.8 billion in 2005/06.

Northern Ireland

By 2005/06, the Northern Ireland executive budget will rise by £1.2 billion, reaching £7.6 billion in 2005/06.

Northern Ireland Office funding will rise from £1.1 billion at present to £1.2 billion in 2005/06.

Trade and Industry

Departmental spending rising from £4.7 billion this year to £535 billion in 2005/06.

Extra spending on science of £1.25 billion a year by 2005/06.

Sustainable energy initiatives will get £28 million.

Foreign Office

Budget to rise from £1.3 billion to £1.5 billion over three years.

British Council budget to rise from £137 million to £185 million by 2005/06.

BBC World Service funding to reach £28 million by 2005/06.

Lord Chancellor's Department

Budget rising from £4.26 billion 2002/03 to £4.79 billion in 2005/06.

Around £650 million will be spent on case management technology for magistrates courts and the Crown Prosecution Service over the next three years.

Transport

Budget to rise from £7.7 billion to £11.6 billion in 2005/06, a 12 per cent real terms increase over three years which will invest more than set out in the original 10-year transport plan.

The funding includes around £1 billion a year to fund the first three years of the London Underground PPP.

HM Treasury

Budget to rise from £4.2 billion this year to £4.8 billion at the end of 2005/06.

Investment in delivering services electronically and combating fraud.

Regional Development Agencies

Budgets will rise from £1.6 billion this year to £2 billion in 2005/06.

Office of Fair Trading

Budget of £33 million this year rising to £55 million by 20055/6.

(source: ePolitix)

Article Index



RCPB(ML) Home Page

Workers' Daily Internet Edition Index Page