WDIE Masthead

Year 2002 No. 18, January 28, 2002 ARCHIVE HOME SEARCH SUBSCRIBE

Waltham Forest and Redbridge Stop the War Conference

Workers' Daily Internet Edition : Article Index :

Waltham Forest and Redbridge Stop the War Conference

Commons Debate on the Coal Industry

Daily On Line Newspaper of the
Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist)

170, Wandsworth Road, London, SW8 2LA. Phone 020 7627 0599
Web Site: http://www.rcpbml.org.uk
e-mail: office@rcpbml.org.uk
Subscription Rates (Cheques made payable to Workers' Publication Centre):
Workers' Weekly Printed Edition:
70p per issue, £2.70 for 4 issues, £17 for 26 issues, £32 for 52 issues (including postage)

Workers' Daily Internet Edition sent by e-mail daily (Text e-mail):
1 issue free, 6 months £5, Yearly £10


Waltham Forest and Redbridge Stop the War Conference

Waltham Forest and Redbridge Stop the War held a very successful conference and teach-in on Sunday, January 20, hosted by Forest YMCA who were also participants. It was attended by around 40 people. Speakers from Stop the War Coalition, CND, Council of Mosques in North East London, Forest YMCA, and from the Campaign for Palestinian Rights delivered informative and thoughtful talks.

The conference was characterised by an atmosphere of discussion and giving space for views to be elaborated. The participants were very keen to take in the information presented in the talks. Each session included lively discussion, with active participation and time to meet up and talk more over refreshments.

The conference ended with a discussion on building the movement against this war. There was a strong sense of the importance of this, and a sense of unity. Issues raised included: the need for the movement to be long-term; the importance of having a coalition uniting the broadest number of people of different allegiances; highlighting and opposing the British government’s role; and that the people should elaborate their own view of the kind of world we need and fight for it.

In this respect a number of key points presented themselves in the discussions. One was that the people should not rely on pressuring the government into doing what is right, but to have a vision and perspective of another world and fight for it. Another point was that it is important not to neglect the criminal role of Tony Blair and Britain by focusing solely on what the US is doing, and thus conciliating with the stand and actions of the British government. It is particularly important here in Britain to aim the struggle at the ruling circles in this country and their actions to impose their values and pursue their interests throughout the globe, in the name of the "war against terrorism", so as to build the movement to dissociate the people from these actions.

What was also characteristic of what the conference pointed towards was opposition to the use of ideology to split the movement, while ensuring that the movement advanced towards its aims, through analysis, and through providing a clear line of march and vision. The aims of opposing the "war on terrorism" have broad support among the people. Everyone is asking where the anti-war movement goes now. One trap being presented for the people is to assert that it has to adopt certain tactics or has to adopt declarations that the problem is imperialism or whatever it might be, rather than furthering the political programme which can be summed up in the slogan, "Not In Our Name", how to bring about a situation where conflicts among nations and countries are not solved by force, and where the people are in a position to decide on these questions. It is incumbent on the advanced forces not to get submerged in the movement or to use the movement for sectarian purposes, but to provide it with orientation and a converging point. The advanced forces will themselves be consolidated in the course of this work.

A detailed report of the conference is being prepared by the organisers.

Article Index



Commons Debate on the Coal Industry

On January 23, 2002, the House of Commons held a debate on the coal industry. We are carrying a report of the debate for the information of our readers.

John Grogan, MP for Selby, said that he is proud to represent the Selby complex, which is the largest remaining coal mine in Britain.

After eulogising the record of the government on dealing with coalfield issues and the coalfield communities since 1997, when they came to office, he said that he wanted to make four points.

He underlined the continuing importance of coal nationally and internationally. Internationally, 40 per cent of all electricity is still generated by coal; there is no indication that that is likely to change. In Britain, just over one third of electricity is generated by coal and £1 billion of national income depends in some way on the coal industry. There are nearly 300 million tonnes of proven reserves of UK coal; BP estimates that perhaps 1 billion tonnes of coal are available for the country's energy needs.

The debate, he said, was taking place against the context of the energy review which, together with the accompanying clean coal technology review, will be published by the end of the month. The background papers to the review suggest that there has been a stark decline in coal-generated power. Energy Paper 68, which was published at the end of 2000, deals with the projections by the Department of Trade and Industry on different energy prices in the years ahead. Importantly, those assumptions depend on the role that the Government envisage for different energy sectors. A critique emerges from the paper; the Government make fairly realistic assumptions about the price of coal, but they underprice oil and gas, which leads to projections of a steeper decline in coal than is likely. In addition, some of the papers come to frightening conclusions about the country's likely dependence on imported energy in future. According to those assumptions, by 2020, we will be 70 per cent dependent on gas, 90 per cent of which will be imported; similar projections were made by the European Commission. How robust that gas supply would be is open to question; only a few weeks ago, the Confederation of UK Coal Producers issued a report, commissioned by the respected risk analysts, the Control Risks Group, which pointed up possible terrorist threats to gas pipelines. However, terrorists do not pose the only possibility of blackmail; there is also a possibility of economic blackmail. If we go down the gas route, he said, we will be in a similar position to the one that we were in the 1970s, but instead of the oil industry holding us to ransom, it will be gas. The head of the Russian gas monopoly, Gazprom, which will be one of the largest gas suppliers in that scenario, recently said:

"It is necessary to create a body which will group countries exporting natural gas, a body that would exercise real concrete regulation of prices."

He continued,

"Everybody should get together to pool their ideas and come up with . . . an agreement about the way we should behave on the market instead of each exporter doing his own thing."

Contrary to projections in Energy Paper 68, John Grogan said, coal burn is increasing in coal-fired power stations and went up last year. PowerGen recently announced plans to reopen coal-fired power stations, so there is a role for coal.

Some people question whether that coal needs to be British, and ask whether some of it could be imported from the international market. There are early signs that that market is tightening; China, for example, is importing coal for the first time. Much Colombian coal, which flooded onto the market some years ago, is now tied up in contracts with the United States. One advantage of coal which has become all too apparent in the past few years in our energy markets, he said, is that coal-generated power can follow the load in the electricity market. It is much easier to increase and decrease the volume of power according to market fluctuations with coal than with renewables or nuclear power. That advantage has become particularly apparent in the workings of the market in recent months.

John Grogan went on to examine the subsidy arrangements. The treaty establishing the European coal and steel community, a feature of European policy since the 1950s, expires towards the end of July 2002. The treaty was designed to expand coalmines. In the aftermath of the war, mines were sunk in the 1950s in many parts of Europe. However, since the 1950s, the European coal and steel treaty has largely been a vehicle for subsidising an industry that has been in decline. It is worth comparing, he said, the scale of subsidy in other European countries with that in Britain. In 2000, the last year for which clear figures are available, approximately 6 billion ecu of aid was given in Germany. In France and Spain, the figure was roughly 1 billion ecu each. By contrast, the figure for the United Kingdom was approximately 142 million ecu. The scale of subsidy was much smaller in the United Kingdom.

There is a message in all that for UK Coal, the major coal producer. There is more than a suspicion that UK Coal plans to concentrate production in fewer pits with more intensive working – possibly 24-hour working – and to move miners from pits that it closes to those that it decides to work intensively. UK Coal is paying reasonable dividends at the moment, no doubt to ward off take-over. If it seeks a subsidy to maintain the coal industry and invest in it, it must specify what is on offer.

The 1997 Department of Trade and Industry review said that the pit at Selby could last until 2009. It is not clear that that will happen on UK Coal's current investment plans. However, there are possibilities of further investment in work in Selby and elsewhere.

John Grogan went on to consider clean coal technology. The latest figures show that CO2 emissions have been stable since 1997. One of the successes of the past few years, he said, is the expansion in the number of companies that are introducing new flue gas desulphurisation plants. Eggborough is an example of that. Such technology was considered unlikely given the dynamics of the market three or four years ago, but it has happened. In America, the Department of Energy contributes $2 billion a year to clean coal. In Japan, the new Sunshine programme means $100 million for clean coal technology.

Whatever happens in terms of the energy review, it is inevitable that there will be coal mine closures in the next decade, John Grogan said. Some pits will become exhausted. It is a challenge to the Government as to how they deal with that. The closures will obviously be on a much smaller scale than in the '50s or '60s, and, indeed, in the '80s, but this will nevertheless be a real challenge for the communities involved.

The official estimate in the Department of Trade and Industry review in 1997 for the closure date of the coalfield at Selby was 2009. If the Government are to ease the closures, when they occur over the coming decades, they should look again at pensions. Managers and pit deputies who are made redundant get a pension at the age of 50 under the arrangements made following privatisation. Ordinary miners, however, do not. Miners have a very physical, back-breaking job, John Grogan said. If miners in this country were given the same rights as their managers and pit deputies – the right to a pension at 50 if made redundant – it would cost about £99 million, according to the actuaries. The mining pension schemes have been in surplus, but this idea will never be promoted by the trustees of the scheme who are elected by the miners, because those miners are all retired. There are no working miners in the scheme. However, half the trustees are now representatives from the DTI, and it would be open to the DTI to explore the possibility of this change, through those trustees. Putting miners on the same footing as their managers would cushion the blow in communities in which there will be closures in the coming decades.

Coal mining is now a modern, flexible industry. It is eager to make its contribution to Britain's energy requirements for many years to come. It would be a pity, he said, now that the industry faces heavy losses owing to the decline in prices following 11 September, if the Government did not build on the achievements of their first term of office to maintain a viable domestic British coal industry.

Adam Price, MP for East Carmarthen and Dinefwr, said that the coal industry is still a significant industry. It employs about 2,000 people in Wales, directly and indirectly. The level of subsidy in the UK compared to the 4.6 billion euros that the coal industry in Germany receives is very small. Coal has to play a part in ensuring a diversity of supply in terms of energy needs. There are other markets for coal. The only suppliers of good quality anthracite to the UK from outside Europe are China and Vietnam, so there is clearly an issue of security of supply involved.

The coal industry has long-term reserves and needs a long-term perspective, but there are short-term costs involved in accessing those reserves. When problems of market failure occur, there is a legitimate role for the Government in helping the industry to overcome issues of short-term costs, to ensure that the coal industry can continue to access the available reserves, probably for the next 50 years.

Later in the debate, Denis Murphy, MP for Wansbeck, said that the coal industry still plays an important role in his constituency. Ellington colliery, which borders Wansbeck, employs some 450 people, and with an unemployment rate that is still twice the national average, those jobs are vital to the local economy. Ellington, however, was not included in the UK coal operating aid package. It is producing today only because the other collieries in the group are receiving financial aid, thereby freeing much needed capital investment for new equipment, enabling the colliery to continue production.

The coal industry's long-term future can be guaranteed only by building a new generation of clean coal power stations, and the Government could assist either by direct grants or by introducing an obligation. Either way, it is important that the current balance of fuels for electricity generation be maintained. Coal, nuclear, gas and renewables all have a role to play, but it is imperative that the UK should not become dependent on gas.

In 1990, total UK gas reserves stood at 36 years. By 2000, that had fallen to 14 years, and 55 to 90 per cent of gas will be imported by 2020. It is reasonable to ask where that gas will come from: 70 per cent of the world's natural gas reserves are concentrated in the Middle East and the former Soviet Union, yet oil companies are pressing ahead with projects such as the $35 billion Yamal pipeline from Siberia. The UK would be at the end of a long pipeline and subject to high transport costs and possible supply interruptions. The choice is simple: coal from the UK or gas from Siberia.

Michael Clapham, MP for Barnsley, West and Penistone, said that the coal industry is a strategic industry, because on current extraction rates, it could last 200 years. There is a continuing need for a coal industry, particularly in respect of the dominance of gas.

He thought that a demonstration plant utilising new IGCC technology should be invested in. That could put in train a new generating set based on new technology, which would be good for British manufacturing and good for the ability to exchange the technology, particularly with economies such as India's and China's. That, too, would be good for British manufacturing.

Colin Burgon, MP for Elmet, noted that the Selby constituency now contains more working pits than any other constituency in Britain. Prior to the great miners' strike of 1984-85, his constituency had three pits and one workshop, and was headquarters of the National Coal Board's northern area, which meant that some 3,500 jobs were provided by the industry. All those jobs have now gone. It is estimated that, within the whole of the Leeds district, only some 200 men are left in mining. He stressed the need to keep open the last remaining pit in the whole of west Yorkshire, the Prince of Wales colliery at Pontefract.

On 3 December, UK Coal announced that work was to be halted on developing a new coalface in the colliery. That move jeopardises the 480 jobs at the colliery. If the pit closes, those, plus another 150 contract workers' jobs, will be at risk, with all the usual knock-on effects. Indeed, Wakefield council estimates a possible loss of some £50 million a year in wages and income, from supplying service industries in the area.

The Prince of Wales colliery has made more than £80 million profit since privatisation in 1995. Unfortunately, it has hit geological problems precisely when UK Coal can no longer call on the current subsidy scheme for assistance. As the Yorkshire coal taskforce has argued, it should be seen as part of a European coal reserve, accessible at a far lower cost base than coal mined elsewhere in the European Union. That would help make the colliery an important asset in accessing reserves, as discussed in the European energy Green Paper.

There is a long history of miners being badly treated, and UK Coal seems determined to continue that tradition. Miners complain of an almost total lack of information. They do not know whether to leave the industry and are convinced that UK Coal is not vitally committed to keeping the pit open. They also suspect that UK Coal wanted to transfer a section of the work force to Kellingly colliery so that it could impose an unpopular four-shift system, so as to fulfil its main aim, the boosting of company profits. On Saturday, he had read in the Yorkshire Post that six options are now being considered for the pit. Gary Foreman, the NACODS – National Association of Colliery Overmen, Deputies and Shotfirers – branch secretary, said that there was a prospect of going into a new seam.

Future generations will look back and judge the privatisation of the coal industry to have been a monumental piece of economic and political vandalism. They will judge the approach taken to a plentiful and reliable energy source to have been profligate and short sighted, and the treatment of those who work in the industry to have been cavalier and thoughtless. Let us hope, in relation to the Prince of Wales colliery, he said, that those judgments will not be sustained.

David Hamilton, MP for Midlothian, said that when he started work in the pits at the age of 15, and then went down the pits at 16, the one thing he knew was that at some point the pits would close. He said that he believed that the security of our future energy needs is key to this whole debate. He referred to two major issues. The first is the fact that the oil and gas industries are finite, although the coal industry has a much longer period before it. There will be major obstacles for nuclear power. If Europe is to survive in the near future, the German, Spanish, French and British coal industries should combine to secure their future. The former Soviet Union and the Middle East have major problems.

In his reply to the debate, the Minister for Industry and Energy, Brian Wilson, said that coal has a major role. The industry provides over a third of the UK's electricity needs. If current trends continue, coal burn is expected to account for between 10 and 22 per cent of electricity generation in 2010. Clearly, coal will continue to play a key role in the UK's energy mix for a long time to come.

On the other hand, he said, the future is not entirely rosy. For geological reasons, some mines will close in the next few years. Realistically, that cannot be avoided. Latest statistics suggest that last year coal production in this country rose by over 4.5 per cent. Over 3.5 million tonnes more coal was burned at power stations in 2001 compared with 2000. Over a third of electricity is generated by coal.

If a truly long-term future for coal is to be secured, it must be consistent with environmental obligations. CO2 emissions in particular will need to be addressed, given the concerns on global warming. That is one of the reasons why the Government announced in June that the case for supporting development of cleaner coal technology was being reviewed. A demonstration plant could play an important part in any future role for coal in the fuel mix. It would ensure security of supply while meeting environmental requirements.

In the course of the clean-coal technology review, the scope for capture and storage of CO2, and the need for Government support for that, have been given particular attention. There are potentially exciting prospects, both for using CO2 to enhance oil recovery from North sea oil wells and to store CO2 permanently underground.

The conclusions of the review into Government support for cleaner coal technology will be published later this month. The PIU energy review is expected to be published around the same time. Both reviews will inform a fresh look at economic and environmental objectives.

A lot depends on those two reviews but the PIU report will be a report to Government, rather than of Government. The debate will begin rather than end with the publication of the PIU report.

He said that the Government are negotiating to put in place a framework for possible national subsidy schemes after July 2002. The aim, he said, is to secure an outcome that will give the flexibility to put in place suitable schemes, should we wish to do so. The key word is "flexibility". Future policy, he said, will be informed by the PIU energy review, the Department of Trade and Industry business support review, the clean coal technology review and the House of Lords reports into security of supply. If the conclusions of those reviews suggest that a further coal subsidy scheme may be appropriate, the Government would consider the issue further.

Article Index



RCPB(ML) Home Page

Workers' Daily Internet Edition Index Page